AUCTION RESERVE APPRAISALS CHEAP!
December 28th, 2007 Posted in Domain Appraisals
Have you ever felt you were bucked off the rodeo horse when the gate opened after setting your reserves too low or too high for a domain auction? You’re not alone. I’ve been seeing a lot of comments on blogs and forums lately from domain sellers worried about setting auction reserve prices too low. Worse, I’ve heard complaints from many domainers that their domains were sold for way less than they wanted. Nothing makes a domainer madder than having a prized domain sold for peanuts in a domain auction. I don’t have to name names for this fact to be broadcast. It has been discussed and is a current topic of discussion in many circles.
It seems that many of the complaints stem from the auction sites requesting that the domainers set their reserve prices at a lower price in order to get them “into the live domain auction”. Some auction services have justified this practice by stating “let the market set the price,” convincing the seller that a lot of buyers will be participating in their live domain auction and drive the “good domains” to their highest market value. Unfortunately, this isn’t always true. Many domain auctions just don’t have the volume of bidders needed to “push” a valuable domain to its reasonable selling price. Most reserves set by sellers aren’t set at the “reasonable” selling price, they’re set at some significantly lower price intended to “entice” bidders.
I personally have had several domains purchased at live domain auctions and in private auctions where only one bidder hit my reserve price and won the domain at my lowest price because of a lack of other bidders. However, sometimes I lowered my price at the “sage advice” of the auction producers. No problem really, I just wanted to see what results would occur based on the “participation of the auction bidders” analysis of my domains’ value. I learned immediately that the smaller the bidding pool, the less chance you had at selling your domain at a fair market price.
I wasn’t disappointed on my sales, because I paid “out of the basket” (virgin registrations) prices for them, so I was making some great profits on $1000+ sales. However, what about those sellers who paid hundreds or thousands of dollars for their domains and sold them in the auction for the same price or even less?
Setting your reserve price is the most important part of placing your domain up for sale on an auction, so it’s important that you get your reserve price near what you want to receive from the auction. Did you ever think why an domain auction service wants you to lower your reserve? Let’s examine the possible reasons why:
1. Auction websites like to see sales. They hope your domain will sell for a lot, but either way, they’re making money. The lower the reserve, the more bidders on the domain (everyone hopes). Nobody wants to see a nice domain with a super low reserve price to lure in bids, and then see that domain sell with one bidder.
Hmmm… there aren’t any other reasons I can think of on why the auction services want you to submit a low reserve. However, with a low reserve, you’ll maybe get one interested party who will buy your domain for a price you didn’t want to sell it for… However, it happens all the time. I’d hazard a guess that at least 40% of all sellers of domains at an auction, live or otherwise, were disappointed at the final sale price. In fact, I’d say that at least 40% of all domains sold at auction sold at the reserve price because there was only one bidder.
I’d say it’s time for a “Domain Auction Reserve Revolution”. Why not let the auction websites know you’re not going to play their game to line their pockets at your expense? You want to be paid what your domain is rightfully worth, right? The facts are that your domain will be sold in a year or two to somebody else for twice as much as what somebody paid you for it at an auction now.
For the New Year of 2008, I would like to see domainers setting a fair market price as their reserve, and let the buyers pay what they know the domain is worth. In this respect, if you want your domains to be appraised for the MINIMUM reserve price that you should ask in an auction, Successclick is offering a special “auction reserve appraisal” for your domains at only $2 a piece in bulk lots of 50 or more. Don’t go into a domain auction and get your pants pulled down around your ankles when someone buys your domain at a ridiculously low price. Contact us now to appraise your domains and help you set your reserve auction prices. Write your request today at:
Successclick (at) gmail.com











5 Responses to “AUCTION RESERVE APPRAISALS CHEAP!”
By Francois on Dec 28, 2007
Stephen, this is so true.
And what makes me crazy is NONE of these auctions are seriously marketed to attract bidders.
It’s a TRUE shame!
They are simply abusing of domainers.
XXXXXXStephenXXXXX
Thanks Francois,
You’re right, and check my response to Prentice’s comment on the ramifications of an auction house not investing in promoting their domain auctions adequately to the business community. If they aren’t investing at least $50,000 in public relations on their auctions, then you may be cheated in receiving the full value of the auction. I can’t point the finger at any one domain auction service, I can only state what is logically sound in the process of offering up your valuable domains for auction and placing a “reserve” price that may be too low, with only one bidder picking it up as a steal.
By Prentice on Dec 28, 2007
Hi Stephen, Great article! As someone who hasn’t yet sold at a live auction you definitely confirm one of my biggest fears. Setting an artificially low reserve, expecting market efficiency to get you a fair price, only to have it sell with a single bid or way less than what you expected.
On the flip side I feel that if a domain fails to meet its reserve, it’s kind of like a negative stigma, signaling to the domain market at large that the domain is not worth more than the highest bid, when the truth of the matter is simply the right players were not participating in the auction, or more likely weren’t even aware the auction was taking place.
I think another reason auction houses pressure for lower reserves is to show a greater volume of domains selling, which is one of the metrics of a successful auction. Live auctions with few sales can be viewed as flops and certainly don’t help an auction house establish its position as a premier sales venue.
XXXXSTEPHENXXXX
Thanks Prentice.
You have made some very astute comments about the auction participation process that I didn’t even think about — the stigma that could be attached to a domain that doesn’t get an offer, not because it isn’t a great domain, but because there weren’t enough bidders, or the right kind of bidders, to fairly engage the auction for the domain.
Many of these auction services state how many “great domains” are for sale, but what have they done to ADVERTISE the fact that these domains are for sale? Have they done due diligence by informing relevant companies that the auction was taking place? Or are they just “preaching to the choir”. Too many times, domains are sold for under value because of the fact that only domainers looking for a great deal are bidding. It’s time that the domain auction services go outside their little worlds and establish connections with REAL buyers in the business community who should be educated on the value of the domains. When will this happen? I don’t know of any auction service that does this, or that provides PROOF that they do this. I would be glad to include any domain auction service’s comments on their marketing promotions to bring in bidders outside the domain industry. Moniker, Snapnames, Afternic, Domaintools, and any other company should post their investments towards the business community as possible participants as bidders in their auctions. This would increase domainers’ trust in throwing in a valuable domain name at lower reserves to see what “the market really will bear”.
By 2w on Jan 1, 2008
My Dear Sir Stephen , happy new year hi ,
perhaps , u may b
1 of the most authorritative at this topic ,
because : :::::
u have been the insider o’[of]
1 of the most successfullest auctions -
the DoMain Round Table
cheers ThANKye , 2w
By 2w on Jan 1, 2008
by ‘the way ,
please blog more ,
because ; ::::
as ‘the insider ,
your experience may be unmateched , 2w
By jeff schneider on Feb 24, 2008
Stephen its hard not to be sarcastic when the auction houses are promoting the fact that there are so many wonderful names up for auction. When they should be promoting the many business opportunities available to small business owners. Instead they promote within the small enclaves of domain speculators. My argument from day one has been show me the end user participation and then and only then will I participate.
To try and circumnavigate the auction alternative, I personally have put up my own showcase site USeBiz.com to promote my names. In support of all the points you have made, it is clear to me that we cannot count on the auction houses to promote our names.
I am so grateful to you Stephen to have the guts to tell the truth.
___________
Jeff Schneider
USeBiz.com